nhaler

  • Random
  • Archive
  • RSS
  • Que?

thecallus:

“There’s no gentle way to put it: People who give in to racism and prejudice may simply be dumb, according to a new study that is bound to stir public controversy. The research finds that children with low intelligence are more likely to hold prejudiced attitudes as adults. These findings point to a vicious cycle, according to lead researcher Gordon Hodson, a psychologist at Brock University in Ontario. Low-intelligence adults tend to gravitate toward socially conservative ideologies, the study found. Those ideologies, in turn, stress hierarchy and resistance to change, attitudes that can contribute to prejudice, Hodson wrote in an email to LiveScience.”

— Low IQ & Conservative Beliefs Linked to Prejudice - Yahoo! News (via brooklynmutt)

Well, no. Let’s not use the same logic that tried to say black people were dumb because of their population IQ scores. This is bad analysis for the same reason The Bell Curve was. Just a roundup:

1. IQ does not measure intelligence. It measures “intelligence”, a loaded word

2. IQ correlates strongly to socioeconomic status, as critics of TBC pointed out at length.

3. Previous studies have shown socioeconomic status and last-place aversion drive prejudiced views - this study likely just confirmed by misinterpreting the equality of IQ test results

One further problem of this study is that it makes the improper leap of attempting to account for the findings. Were it to simply stop at “Conservatives tend to have lower IQ scores”, it would remain at that: an acknowledgement of tendency. 

But the fact that they try to infer a causal relationship between the two—faultily, as you’ve pointed out—is overstepping their ability and resources (as it appears, anyway) to actually deduce with any authority its veracity. Since I’m really not that interested, I can’t be bothered to check. 

However, it also appears that we’re not being presented the full story. As the media will discover, the simplification of this story into its current format is sure to attract traffic, reinforce prejudices, arouse public discussion, and further, discredit the field of psychology when the inevitable conclusion is reached that this story is bunk. The implications are great on all sides. 

An additional problem with this is the left/right political binary stereotype that is reinforced: the smart vs the dumb;  left vs the right; strong vs weak; rich vs poor etc, which, instead of actually providing insight, only reinforces that perception of separation. A comprehensive review of the study, at this point, would be moot, since its findings and the conclusions wouldn’t be relevant to the discourse produced immediately hand as a result of its original publication. 

Source: Yahoo!

  • 4 months ago > brooklynmutt
  • 472
  • Permalink
  • Share
    Tweet

472 Notes/ Hide

  1. activisminspiration reblogged this from thatluciegirl
  2. processingde9 liked this
  3. coalitiong9p liked this
  4. eclecticpasstime reblogged this from grief-bacon
  5. alexwhatson reblogged this from arainbowofgrey
  6. theworldisconfused liked this
  7. arainbowofgrey reblogged this from ilyagerner
  8. thebeatingdrum reblogged this from ilyagerner
  9. youshouldbesafenow reblogged this from notemily
  10. florizel36 reblogged this from johndylanger and added:
    Way to go Brock University!
  11. datgucciboi reblogged this from bastard-brother
  12. ariannamoe reblogged this from johndylanger
  13. matthatesonions reblogged this from educrate
  14. 52hearts liked this
  15. paulina liked this
  16. anarttoeverything liked this
  17. justinthomas liked this
  18. rethinkagain reblogged this from brooklynmutt
  19. beyond-the-madness reblogged this from forrestbondurant
  20. hi-imkatie liked this
  21. strudel-cutie reblogged this from youcantdanceontheghetto
  22. cstardust reblogged this from ralphdgamf
  23. peaslouise reblogged this from thatluciegirl
  24. insanityplz reblogged this from moyaofthemist
  25. razor-to-the-rosary reblogged this from fishnetandfundip
  26. moyaofthemist reblogged this from justaphotograph
  27. petersheik liked this
  28. nothingtothetable reblogged this from nedhepburn
  29. lightheaded-heavyheart reblogged this from futuristicprostitute
  30. elpy17 reblogged this from futuristicprostitute and added:
    God, this depresses me.
  31. commanderspock liked this
  32. hiddlestupid reblogged this from consultingasshole
  33. aphrodite5239 liked this
  34. darkpassengerdriving liked this
  35. consultingasshole reblogged this from futuristicprostitute
  36. fishnetandfundip reblogged this from futuristicprostitute
  37. formermaleprostitute liked this
  38. consultingasshole liked this
  39. illneverloseaffection liked this
  40. futuristicprostitute reblogged this from not-applicable
  41. ravencolours liked this
  42. parrri liked this
  43. brooklynmutt posted this
← Previous • Next →

About

Avatar
  • phōtōs
Booze, sex, depressing reality, feminism, personalism, drugs, decadence, cinema, fetishism, politics, media/journalism, and most offensively: occasional art, and pithy comments & outbursts related to all of the above. This blog categorically reflects the views of all Southern-Ontarians without exception.

Pages

  • who.is
  • Kromapix →
  • Blōg Entries
  • Rants
  • Texts

Me, elsewhere

  • gregof89 on Vimeo
  • kromapix on Flickr
  • lastnhaler on Last.fm
  • Google

Following

  • RSS
  • Random
  • Archive
  • Que?
  • Mobile

Effector Theme by Carlo Franco.

Powered by Tumblr